I Hate DRM

A site dedicated to reclaiming consumer digital rights.
Welcome to I Hate DRM Sign in | Join | Help
in Search

I Hate DRM Blog

HD DVD and Blu-Ray Copy Protection is a Joke

AACS is one of the copy protection algorithms used to keep HD DVD and Blu-Ray DVD out of the hands of those dirty, nasty pirates everywhere.  One of the ways it accomplishes it is by using an encrypted key to make sure your content is "original".  These keys can be revoked which would render all "copied" material unreadable (or something like that).

A few months ago, a number of hackers found how to hack the keys to copy the material.  Now, new keys have been released to thwart those nasty pirates and once again, they have been able to hack them.  This time though, a week before DVDs bearing these new keys were released to the public.

The creators of these copy protection scams truly don't understand how these people work.  The people responsible for "hacking" the keys most likely have no interest in making money or selling pirated goods.  They do it for the challenge.  Remember when you were a kid and your parents told you that you couldn't do something....exactly.  You wanted to do it 100 times more.  It's human nature.  These "hackers" (or should we call them content liberators), are just following human nature.  And as long as we have these stupid "restriction controls" in place like AACS, there will be those who will find a way around it.

Is it any wonder why all this stuff cost as much as it does?  Have you looked at the retail price of a HD DVD?  $30 in most cases.  That's almost twice the cost of a regular DVD.  My advice to all these companies that buy so heavily into copy protection is this; stop using it.  Save that money and figure out how to COMPETE with pirates, not beat them.  Beating them will never happen.  Maybe then you will be able to offer value to your customers.  Have fun fighting a losing battle and meanwhile, count me out as a customer.

Published Thursday, May 17, 2007 1:13 PM by IHateDRMAdmin

Comments

 

goatimus said:

The business model for pricing a high def movie at $30 is totally cracked out.  If you're used to watching regular DVDs the picture is quite good.  I have high def broadcast (antenna) reception, and can easily compare HD versions of movies to the 720p DVD version....  can I tell the difference yes!  Does it warrant an extra $15 or for an on-sale DVD an extra $20?  NO NO NO!!  And ignoring the cost of the player, does it warrant the requirement of an HDCP bug-riddled connection only for the hassle?  Hahahaha....

I have a LOT of movies in my collection because I'd rather pay for DVD movies than 50 channels of useless cable full of shopping channels, news, public service etc.  Even with this in mind, there is no way possible I could justify the hassle, annoyance and expense of HD movies.  They can keep it.  I hope they choke on the R&D costs.  If they come back with $15 or less per disk and non-encrypted HDMI/DVI capability, I might think about it.  The HD format does not properly scale in price compared to the commoner's viewing pleasure.
May 18, 2007 6:45 PM
 

goatimus said:

And yet another reason for the HDMI interface to die a horrible death in favor of a better and consumer friendly design:

http://www.audioholics.com/education/cables/whats-the-matter-with-hdmi
May 19, 2007 8:27 AM
 

dashwarts said:

The challenge is always one thing that fuels my amateur hacking. The corruption of companies and bad formats fuel the rest. Some devices you could pick up at most computer stores, if used properly, can be used to get around copy protection on almost ANYTHING if you run WinXP/Linux... NOT ON THE EVIL VISTA!

P.S. I agree with goatimus on HDCP.
May 28, 2007 4:11 PM
Anonymous comments are disabled

This Blog

Post Calendar

<May 2007>
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
293012345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
272829303112
3456789

Syndication

Powered by Community Server, by Telligent Systems